Comparison table: SCAN Health Plan vs. Humana
| Aspect | SCAN Health Plan | Humana |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | Nonprofit, Medicare-only focus, headquartered in Long Beach | For-profit, national insurer, headquartered in Louisville, KY |
| Network type | Mostly HMO, some HMO-POS by county | HMO and PPO depending on county and plan |
| Extra benefits | OTC, dental/vision/hearing, transportation; local focus | OTC, dental/vision/hearing, wellness; nationwide lineup |
| Star rating | Varies by plan and year; historically competitive | Varies by plan and year; confirm by specific plan |
| Geographic availability | Focused on Southern California (LA, Orange, San Diego, Riverside) | Nationwide presence, including all of Southern California |
Neither SCAN nor Humana is the right choice for everyone: SCAN tends to win out when you want an HMO plan focused specifically on Southern California older adults, while Humana tends to win out when you value a national insurer with a broad lineup of supplemental benefits and, in some counties, PPO options. The right answer depends on your county, whether your doctors are in the exact plan's network, and your medications. Plans, networks, and benefits for both insurers change every year and vary by county, so always confirm the details against your current plan's Evidence of Coverage before deciding.
SCAN vs Humana is a common comparison among Southern California residents choosing a Medicare Advantage plan, because both insurers have a strong presence in the region but with very different models: SCAN is a nonprofit organization founded in Long Beach and focused almost exclusively on Medicare, while Humana is one of the largest for-profit insurers in the country, with a nationwide lineup of Medicare Advantage plans.
This is an educational, neutral guide, not a recommendation of any specific plan. Both insurers' benefits, networks, and premiums change every year, and exact availability varies by county and ZIP code, so use this comparison as a starting point for asking the right questions before enrolling.
Who SCAN Health Plan and Humana are
SCAN Health Plan was founded in Long Beach decades ago as a nonprofit organization focused exclusively on Medicare Advantage for Southern California, with a historical presence in Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, and San Diego counties. Humana, by contrast, is a national for-profit insurer headquartered in Louisville, Kentucky, offering Medicare Advantage plans in most states, including a broad presence across Southern California.
Provider and hospital network: SCAN vs. Humana
SCAN builds HMO networks specific to each county, contracting directly with doctors, independent medical groups, and local Southern California hospitals. Humana contracts its own network nationwide, with specific contracts by county and plan that often translate into a broad lineup of hospitals and specialists, including PPO options that SCAN does not offer as widely.
If your primary doctor and specialists are already part of one plan's network, that continuity usually outweighs every other factor in this comparison. If your doctors are spread across different hospital systems, it is worth checking each plan's exact directory before deciding.
Availability, cost, benefits, and eligibility vary by person, product, contract, and insurance company, as well as by your service area. Guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. Karla Arámburo is not affiliated with or endorsed by Medicare or the federal government.
Costs and premiums: what to expect from each insurer
Both SCAN and Humana offer $0 monthly premium plans in many Southern California counties, plus premium plans in some cases, but the real cost — deductibles, specialist copays, drug coinsurance, and maximum out-of-pocket — varies by specific plan, not by the insurer's name. No amount stays the same every year: it should always be confirmed in the official Evidence of Coverage (EOC) for the current plan year before comparing or enrolling.
To understand the Part B Giveback benefit that some plans from both insurers offer to reduce your Part B premium, review our Part B Giveback benefit guide.
Part D drug coverage: SCAN vs. Humana
Both insurers include Part D drug coverage within their MA-PD plans, but each manages its own formulary, with cost-sharing tiers and prior authorization or step therapy rules that can differ noticeably between SCAN and Humana for the same medication. A brand-name drug may sit on a preferred tier with one insurer and require prior authorization with the other.
The only reliable way to know which covers your prescriptions better is to compare your exact medication list, with the doses you actually take, against the current formulary of each specific plan you're considering, instead of assuming one insurer covers medications better in general.
Extra benefits: dental, vision, OTC, and more
SCAN and Humana offer supplemental benefits on most of their plans, including an OTC/flex card for over-the-counter products, dental, vision, and hearing benefits, and transportation to medical appointments, but the exact amount, number of covered trips, and participating stores change from one specific plan to another and from year to year. Humana tends to stand out for a broad nationwide lineup of wellness and fitness programs, while SCAN tends to focus on community-support programs aimed specifically at Southern California older adults.
To understand how the OTC/flex card works in more detail, regardless of insurer, review our OTC/flex card guide, and for dental, vision, and hearing our guide to those benefits.
Star ratings: SCAN vs. Humana
CMS star ratings are awarded per specific plan and county, not per insurer overall. SCAN and Humana have each had, in different years, 4-star and 5-star plans in Southern California, and neither insurer keeps the same rating across all of its plans consistently. Review our Star Ratings guide to understand how they're calculated and why a 5-star plan can give you a Special Enrollment Period to switch at any time of year.
County availability: Orange, Los Angeles, San Diego, and Riverside
Both SCAN and Humana offer multiple plans across Orange County, Los Angeles County, San Diego County, and Riverside County, but the exact number of plans, their benefits, and ZIP-code availability change every Annual Enrollment Period. A plan available in Anaheim may not be available in Riverside, and vice versa, even within the same insurer.
I work with families in cities such as Anaheim, Los Angeles and Riverside, reviewing in each case which SCAN and Humana plans are actually available in their exact ZIP code, instead of assuming availability across an entire county.
When does SCAN make sense, and when does Humana make sense?
SCAN tends to suit members looking for a plan focused specifically on Medicare, with support benefits geared toward independent Southern California older adults, who are comfortable with a local HMO structure. Humana tends to suit those who value a broader nationwide network, an extensive lineup of wellness programs, or who travel frequently outside Southern California and prefer the flexibility of a PPO plan.
If you have both Medicare and Medi-Cal, first review our D-SNP guide for dual eligibility, since both SCAN and Humana offer specific D-SNP plans whose availability and provider network vary by county. To see how SCAN compares against other insurers, also review our general SCAN Health Plan comparison and our SCAN vs. UnitedHealthcare comparison.
No amount or figure in this table replaces the plan's official Evidence of Coverage (EOC) for the specific year; costs, networks, and ratings change every Annual Enrollment Period.
Free, unbiased bilingual help comparing
I am Karla Arámburo, an independent, bilingual insurance agent licensed in California to serve families in Orange, Los Angeles, San Diego, and Riverside counties. As an independent agent, I am not limited to SCAN Health Plan or Humana: I review your current doctors, your medications, and your budget, and compare the specific plans available in your ZIP code, in Spanish or English, at no cost to you. I also offer life insurance options that accept an ITIN for families without a Social Security number.
You can call or text (619) 321-8733 or schedule a free consultation. This page is general education, not individualized advice or a recommendation of a specific plan or insurer.
Frequently asked questions
SCAN vs Humana: which is better for Medicare Advantage?
There is no universal answer: it depends on your county, whether your doctors and hospitals are in the exact plan's network, your medications, and whether you value a local focus or a national network more. SCAN tends to suit those looking for an HMO plan centered specifically on Southern California; Humana tends to suit those who value a national insurer with a broad lineup of supplemental benefits and, in some counties, PPO options.
Is SCAN Health Plan better than Humana for Medicare Advantage?
Neither insurer is automatically better. SCAN is a nonprofit organization focused only on Medicare in Southern California, while Humana is a national for-profit insurer with a presence in nearly every part of the country. The best option depends on whether your preferred network of doctors is contracted with one or the other specific plan in your ZIP code.
SCAN Health Plan vs Humana Medicare Advantage: which has more extra benefits?
Both insurers offer supplemental benefits on most of their plans, such as an OTC/flex card, dental, vision, and hearing benefits, and transportation to medical appointments, but the exact amount and specific services vary from plan to plan and change every year. Humana tends to stand out for a broad lineup of nationwide wellness programs; SCAN tends to stand out for community-support programs focused on Southern California.
Which has more doctors in its network, SCAN or Humana?
It cannot be known in general. SCAN contracts a specific local network by Southern California county, while Humana builds its network nationwide with contracts that vary widely by county and plan. The only reliable way to know is to look up your specific doctors in the exact plan's directory you're considering.
Which has a better star rating, SCAN or Humana?
CMS star ratings are awarded per specific plan and county, not per insurer overall, and both SCAN and Humana have had 4-star and 5-star plans in different years. Check the rating of the exact plan you're considering for the current coverage year, since it can change even within the same insurer.
Does Humana offer PPO plans while SCAN is HMO-only?
Generally yes, though it is not an absolute rule. SCAN primarily offers HMO plans, with some HMO-POS options in certain areas. Humana offers both HMO and PPO depending on the county, and its PPO plans are often a popular choice for those who want to see out-of-network specialists under certain conditions. The exact availability depends on the plan and the county where you live.
Does SCAN or Humana have more plans available in Riverside County?
Both insurers offer several plans in Riverside County, as well as in Orange, Los Angeles, and San Diego, but the exact number and benefits of each plan change every Annual Enrollment Period. Real availability for your ZIP code is only confirmed with the current plan finder or by reviewing options with a locally licensed agent.
Can you help me compare SCAN and Humana in my ZIP code?
Yes. I review your current doctors, your medications, and your budget, and compare the specific SCAN, Humana, and other plans available in your Southern California ZIP code, in Spanish or English, at no cost to you.
To compare other local networks with SCAN, read SCAN vs Blue Shield, SCAN vs Anthem Blue Cross and SCAN vs Health Net. Always confirm the doctors, benefits and availability of the exact plan in your ZIP code.
Related guides
Written by Karla Arámburo, licensed California insurance agent (License #4431554, NPN 21399485)
