Medicare comparison

SCAN Health Plan vs. Kaiser Permanente Medicare Advantage in Southern California

By Karla Arámburo Published October 14, 2026
Comparison at a glance
TopicComparison from this guide
Who each insurer is and how it is organizedSCAN Health Plan is a nonprofit organization founded in California in 1977, dedicated exclusively to serving Medicare-age adults. Unlike national for-profit insurers, SCAN contracts with a network of independent doctors and hospitals centered on Southern California, and it builds its plans and wellness programs specifically around this population's needs, without offering insurance for other age groups.
Network structure: independent HMO vs. closed, integrated HMOBoth insurers primarily offer HMO plans, but the structure behind each network is very different. SCAN contracts with doctors, independent medical groups (IPAs), and hospitals from different systems across Southern California, which tends to translate into more hospital variety within the same plan, though with the typical HMO rules: a primary care doctor and referrals for specialists.
Costs, premiums, and typical deductiblesBoth insurers offer plans with monthly premiums starting at $0 in most Southern California counties, and the real cost depends more on copays for office visits, specialists, and hospital stays, plus the annual out-of-pocket maximum, than on the advertised premium. Drug deductibles also vary by specific plan: some plans from both insurers have no Part D deductible, while others apply the maximum deductible Medicare allows for certain drug tiers.

SCAN Health Plan and Kaiser Permanente are two of the most-searched-by-name options for Medicare Advantage in Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, and San Diego counties, but they start from very different models. This guide compares them objectively, without recommending one over the other, because the best option depends on your current doctors, your medications, your budget, and the county where you live, not on which insurer is better known among older adults. Both change their plan lineup, networks, and benefits every year, and those details vary from one county to another, so treat this guide as a starting point, not the final comparison for your specific ZIP code.

Who each insurer is and how it is organized

SCAN Health Plan is a nonprofit organization founded in California in 1977, dedicated exclusively to serving Medicare-age adults. Unlike national for-profit insurers, SCAN contracts with a network of independent doctors and hospitals centered on Southern California, and it builds its plans and wellness programs specifically around this population's needs, without offering insurance for other age groups.

Kaiser Permanente is an integrated health system: it owns its own hospitals, clinics, and pharmacies, and almost all of its Medicare Advantage plans are HMOs within that closed network. This tends to appeal to people who already receive care within the Kaiser system and value having medical history, appointments, and lab results connected in one place, while SCAN appeals to those who prefer choosing among a broader network of independent providers specialized in care for older adults.

Network structure: independent HMO vs. closed, integrated HMO

Both insurers primarily offer HMO plans, but the structure behind each network is very different. SCAN contracts with doctors, independent medical groups (IPAs), and hospitals from different systems across Southern California, which tends to translate into more hospital variety within the same plan, though with the typical HMO rules: a primary care doctor and referrals for specialists.

Kaiser Permanente, by contrast, operates a closed, integrated HMO model: you generally must choose a primary care doctor within the Kaiser system and get referrals to see specialists, all within the same network of hospitals, clinics, and pharmacies that Kaiser owns. If your current doctor is not part of Kaiser or SCAN's contracted network, you would need to switch to keep coverage with either one. Our Medicare Advantage guide explains how HMO networks work in general before comparing specific insurers.

Availability, cost, benefits, and eligibility vary by person, product, contract, and insurance company, as well as by your service area. Guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. Karla Arámburo is not affiliated with or endorsed by Medicare or the federal government.

Costs, premiums, and typical deductibles

Both insurers offer plans with monthly premiums starting at $0 in most Southern California counties, and the real cost depends more on copays for office visits, specialists, and hospital stays, plus the annual out-of-pocket maximum, than on the advertised premium. Drug deductibles also vary by specific plan: some plans from both insurers have no Part D deductible, while others apply the maximum deductible Medicare allows for certain drug tiers.

No specific plan automatically costs less for being from one insurer or another; the real cost depends on the exact plan, the county, and your care needs during the year. Comparing each specific plan's Evidence of Coverage (EOC), not just the monthly premium, is the only reliable way to know which costs less for your situation.

Prescription drug coverage (Part D) and extra benefits

Most Medicare Advantage plans from both insurers include integrated drug coverage (MAPD), but each manages its own formulary, with its own list of covered drugs and its own copay tiers. Verifying that your specific medications, at their exact dosages, are on the formulary of the plan you're considering is the most important step before choosing either one, since the same medication can cost very differently between a SCAN plan and a Kaiser Permanente plan.

On extra benefits, SCAN tends to highlight programs specifically for older adults, such as support for family caregivers and community wellness services, while Kaiser coordinates dental, vision, and hearing benefits within its own affiliated network. Both include an OTC/flex card and transportation to medical appointments on most of their plans. To understand these benefits regardless of insurer, review our dental, vision, and hearing benefits guide, our OTC/flex card guide and our transportation and meal benefits guide.

Star ratings and county availability

CMS star ratings are awarded per specific plan and county, not per insurer overall, and both companies have received high ratings on different plans in different years. A 5-star plan lets you switch at any point during the year through a Special Enrollment Period, so it's worth confirming the rating of the exact plan you are considering, not just the overall average for SCAN or Kaiser Permanente. See our star ratings guide for more detail. In Los Angeles County and Orange County, both insurers have a broad presence, while in parts of the Inland Empire, SCAN's availability can be more limited than Kaiser's. Exact availability changes by ZIP code and by year, so it should always be confirmed for your specific address. I work with families in cities such as Glendora and Whittier, reviewing in each case which SCAN and Kaiser Permanente plans are actually available in their exact ZIP code.

How to choose with help from a licensed agent

If you value a broader network of independent doctors specialized in geriatric care, or prefer the focus of a nonprofit organization dedicated exclusively to Medicare, it is worth comparing the SCAN plans available in your county. If you already see your doctors within Kaiser Permanente and value having everything — doctor, specialist, hospital, and pharmacy — in one system, a Kaiser HMO plan can give you continuity and a predictable premium. Our comparison of SCAN Health Plan vs. Medicare Advantage in general explains how SCAN fits within the broader Medicare Advantage landscape, and our comparison of Health Net vs. Kaiser Permanente helps you compare even more options before the Annual Enrollment Period (AEP).

Free, unbiased bilingual help comparing

I am Karla Arámburo, an independent, bilingual insurance agent licensed in California to serve families in Orange, Los Angeles, San Diego, and Riverside counties. As an independent agent, I am not limited to SCAN, Kaiser Permanente, or any particular insurer: I review your current doctors, your medications, your eligibility, and your budget, and compare the specific plans available in your ZIP code, in Spanish or English, at no cost to you. I also offer life insurance options that accept an ITIN for families without a Social Security number.

You can call or text (619) 321-8733 or schedule a free consultation. This page is general education, not individualized advice or a recommendation of a specific product or insurer.

Frequently asked questions

Is SCAN Health Plan available throughout Southern California?

Not equally in every county. SCAN has a strong historical presence in Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, and San Bernardino counties, but its exact availability by plan and ZIP code changes every year during the Annual Enrollment Period. Kaiser Permanente, by contrast, operates where it has its own integrated medical centers, which also varies by county.

Is SCAN a nonprofit insurer?

Yes. SCAN Health Plan is a nonprofit organization founded in California specifically to serve Medicare-age adults, and it focuses on HMO plans designed around that population's needs. Kaiser Permanente also operates under a nonprofit structure for its health plan, but with a different integrated-care model, where it directly owns its hospitals and clinics.

Are SCAN plans HMO or PPO?

SCAN primarily offers HMO plans, with a contracted network of independent doctors and hospitals that varies by county, and in some areas it also offers HMO-POS plans with some added flexibility. Kaiser Permanente is almost exclusively HMO within its own integrated system. Neither insurer offers PPO broadly in Southern California under Medicare Advantage.

How do extra benefits like transportation and OTC compare between SCAN and Kaiser?

Both insurers offer supplemental benefits on most of their plans, including an OTC/flex card, transportation to medical appointments, and dental, vision, and hearing benefits, but the exact amount, the number of covered trips, and participating stores change from one specific plan to another and from year to year. SCAN tends to highlight wellness and community-support programs aimed specifically at older adults, while Kaiser coordinates these benefits within its own network of affiliated clinics.

Which has a better star rating, SCAN or Kaiser Permanente?

CMS star ratings are awarded per specific plan and county, not per insurer overall, and both companies have received 4-star and 5-star ratings on different plans in different years. The rating of your exact plan, not the insurer's average, is what determines whether you qualify for a Special Enrollment Period to switch into a 5-star plan.

Which insurer is better for someone with Medi-Medi dual eligibility?

Both offer D-SNP (Dual Eligible Special Needs Plans) designed for people with both Medicare and Medi-Cal, but the exact availability of these plans by county and the provider networks that coordinate with Medi-Cal vary. Review our C-SNP vs. D-SNP guide and confirm with an agent which specific D-SNP plan is available in your ZIP code.

Can you help me compare specific SCAN and Kaiser Permanente plans in my ZIP code?

Yes. I review your current doctors, your medications, and your budget, and compare the specific SCAN, Kaiser Permanente, and other Medicare Advantage plans available in your ZIP code, in Spanish or English, at no cost to you.

To compare other local networks with SCAN, read SCAN vs Blue Shield, SCAN vs Anthem Blue Cross and SCAN vs Health Net. Always confirm the doctors, benefits and availability of the exact plan in your ZIP code.

Written by Karla Arámburo, licensed California insurance agent (License #4431554, NPN 21399485)

Want to review your options?

Schedule a no-cost, no-pressure conversation.

Talk with Karla

Optional measurement

Allow visits and requests to be measured with ChatGPT Ads and Google Analytics? Form contents are not shared. You can reject or change your choice; the form works either way. Privacy